Skip to content
Secret Yarnery
0 items in cart

Cart

Your cart is empty.

crochet podcast

Knooking: Our 10-Minute Try Took 50 Minutes: Podcast 190

· Christa Patel

Knooking: Our 10-Minute Try Took 50 Minutes: Podcast 190

Our plan to try the technique in 10 minutes turned into 50 minutes, about seven rows, and plenty of laughter. In our first knooking session, Rachel and I made fabric with a knitted texture. We expected knitting with a crochet hook to feel familiar, but getting our hands to cooperate took longer than expected.

If you're following a knooking tutorial and already know how to crochet, some of our first steps will look familiar. The trouble started when we tried to carry those familiar movements into a different technique, beginning with a rather confused reading of the instructions.

Key Takeaways

  • Our planned 10-minute knooking try took about 50 minutes and produced roughly seven rows of knitted-texture fabric.
  • Familiar crochet movements helped with the foundation chain, but our usual grip and yarn tension made the stitches harder to manage.
  • The knit stitch became easier to repeat; purling, catching the yarn, and keeping loops an even size took more practice.
  • Watching a demonstration helped clarify the movements, while dropped stitches and undoing work remained difficult during our first session.

Our First False Start Was the Instruction Sheet

I invited Rachel over, brought out the knook kit I'd ordered from Amazon, and suggested we learn together. Beginners can also compare Leisure Arts kits when shopping for supplies. Rachel is a prolific crocheter, so we had plenty of crochet experience between us. Neither of us knew what we were doing.

We sat outside and divided the jobs: I would read, and Rachel would try the practical part. That arrangement might have worked better if I'd started with the right instructions.

Instead, we found ourselves reading about knitting accessories that didn't seem to match what we were trying to do. We searched through the directions, wondered whether something was missing, and finally realized we were looking at the knitting instructions.

Once we found the directions, we could begin.

The knook itself felt unfamiliar, and threading the cord through the knook hook took some fiddling. It felt snug enough that I thought the cord was stuck, until it finally went through.

Our ten-minute challenge was already looking ambitious.

Knooking: Our 10-Minute Try Took 50 Minutes: Podcast 190

The Foundation Started with Familiar Crochet Moves

The Slip knot and chain were familiar crochet basics, and together they formed our foundation chain. The instructions called the starting method a crochet hook cast on. That cast on left us with a loop on the hook that didn't count as a chain.

Although those first movements felt familiar, the hook itself didn't. After a day of crocheting, using something that felt so different in my hand was distracting. Like Tunisian crochet, knooking keeps loops on a hook, but the stitches are formed differently.

Then we reached the part where our crochet habits stopped helping.

Rachel's work initially felt to her like ordinary crochet with something attached to the end of the hook. When I asked whether she was leaving her loops on, she wasn't. She'd continued crocheting in the way her hands already knew.

We began keeping the loops on the hook, then moving them onto the cord as we worked through the directions. Turning to work back across those loops brought another round of uncertainty: how much room to leave, where the working yarn belonged, and what to do with the cord already running through the previous stitches.

We were reading, trying something, and then looking at each other's work to see whether it made sense.

Holding the Hook Became Its Own Challenge

Rachel didn't like the loops passing beyond her fingers. She wanted to keep them close, but then everything bunched together.

I kept thinking we could move the stitches farther back. As we continued, though, I also found it awkward to reach the next loop once the stitches sat underneath my hand.

The farther we went across a row, the less comfortable the grip became. Rachel noticed that she had less work left in her other hand to help guide things near the end.

Our Crochet Tension Came Along Too

Some loops looked reasonably even until we tried to work into them. Then we'd discover that one was much smaller or tighter than the others.

Rachel's early piece felt stiff. Meanwhile, I kept trying to make each new loop larger because the tiny ones were becoming difficult to catch.

I also kept reverting to my usual crochet yarn wrap. I'd start a row determined to follow one method, then realize a few stitches later that my hands had returned to their old habits.

We joked that knooking called for Chamomile tea rather than coffee.

17 1200x1200

Relaxing our tension sounded simple, but remembering to do it while managing the hook and cord was another matter. We hadn't tried shaping the fabric with an increase or a decrease yet; we were still learning the basic stitches.

The Knitted Texture Kept Us Interested

Even while we struggled with the movements, we liked the fabric.

Our little pieces had recognizable knitting definition. They also felt thinner and looked looser than the crochet fabric we were used to making, with less yarn piled on top of itself.

That was enough to keep us going.

Rachel had struggled with knitting before because stitches would fall off the needles. During this attempt, she liked seeing the loops sitting on the cord. Later, I still managed to lose stitches while working, so that didn't spare us every problem.

We also enjoyed pulling the hook through and settling the completed row onto the cord. That became the most satisfying part of the process.

By around 12 minutes, we'd produced only a small amount of work. We laughed about how much Rachel could have crocheted in the same time. She's fast with a crochet hook, but neither of us was moving quickly here.

The Knit Stitch Began to Make Sense

Once we'd worked a few rows, we started to gather a little speed. I wasn't certain that every stitch matched the one before it, and I hadn't been counting consistently, but we were making fabric.

The knit stitch was the part we felt more comfortable repeating.

Rachel still preferred keeping the stitches close together. I was trying to find enough space to work without letting the loops shrink. Neither of us had settled into a comfortable hold, but we could see progress.

Then I decided to figure out purling.

At first, I thought changing how I wrapped the yarn might be the answer. Rachel pointed out that we could try entering the loop from the other side.

That sent us back to the instructions, where we discovered the purl information we'd been trying to work out for ourselves.

Knooking: Our 10-Minute Try Took 50 Minutes: Podcast 190

Purling Was Much Harder to Repeat

The distinction we were trying to follow was where the working yarn stayed and which direction we entered the loop.

For our purl attempts, the instructions put the yarn at the front and described entering from the back toward the front. The yarn-in-front position also appears in the Goats and Hounds knooking tutorial.

Reading those words was much easier than getting my hands to follow them.

One Successful Row Didn't Make It Automatic

For a while, I thought I was pretending to purl. The movements felt awkward, and I couldn't tell whether I'd changed anything useful.

Then I finished a row, looked at the fabric, and thought I'd managed the purl stitch. I was delighted. After all that struggling, seeing the different texture felt like a proper achievement.

Rachel wasn't convinced she'd done anything different. Later, she could see a section where she'd changed the stitch, followed by another section where she'd slipped back into the familiar movement.

That kept happening to both of us. We'd understand what we meant to do, then lose track partway through the row.

Knooking: Our 10-Minute Try Took 50 Minutes: Podcast 190

Tiny Loops Made Everything Slower

My purl attempts also brought back the tension problem. Some loops became so small that getting them onto the hook took a lot of concentration.

At one point, I joked that I was taking about 30 seconds per stitch, and the stitch might still be wrong.

Catching the yarn became another problem. Even near the end of our session, Rachel was struggling to catch it cleanly. Knowing where the yarn belonged hadn't made that movement dependable.

Ribbing combines knit and purl stitches, but we weren't ready to try it.

Eventually, our conversation came back to a much smaller goal:

"I think you need to master one stitch before we try the next."

I was quite ready to defend garter stitch by then.

Frogging Was Another Skill We Hadn't Learned

Undoing crochet is familiar territory. Undoing our first attempt wasn't.

When Rachel tried to go backward, she had to work out how to remove stitches and put them back without losing them. The loops held for the next row are live loops. We struggled to pick up stitches and return them to the hook or cord. We didn't arrive at a tidy correction method during the session.

Meanwhile, counting exposed mistakes I'd missed while concentrating on the movement.

I realized I'd dropped two stitches during one attempt. Then another count showed that I'd already lost one earlier. The missing stitches weren't obvious to me while I was working.

After some careful rearranging, I finally counted back to 12 stitches. Getting them all back felt like an achievement of its own.

However, fixing the work created another problem: I'd put things back so I was working at the wrong end of my cord. I didn't understand why it felt wrong until Rachel noticed what had happened.

By then, we were spending as much time recovering our work as adding to it.

We Finally Put On a Demonstration

After struggling with the written directions, we decided to watch someone do it.

I mentioned Totally Fierce Crochet & Knooking while looking for help. The channel's beginner lesson also appears in this knooking tutorial playlist.

The video tutorial covered stockinette stitch worked flat and in the round. Its method for knooking in the round could help with projects such as knooking socks. Seeing the movement gave us something clearer to compare with our own attempts.

The knitting part looked more familiar by then. Purling still needed work, but I found the demonstrated method easier to understand than what I'd been trying to piece together from the page.

A printed resource from Leisure Arts could also help clarify the steps alongside a demonstration.

It didn't instantly fix our hands. I still lost track of what I'd done on the previous row, and Rachel continued struggling to catch the yarn.

We laughed that watching first might have helped. Reading the correct instructions first would also have been useful.

Fifty Minutes Later, We Had About Seven Rows

Our ten-minute challenge stretched to about 50 minutes. We managed roughly seven rows, with my piece around 1½ inches and Rachel's closer to 2 inches.

We hadn't made a blanket, sweater, scarf, or slippers. At our pace, even a mug rug sounded like a substantial undertaking.

Rachel joked that she'd be a granny by the time she finished the square. Considering how quickly she normally crochets granny squares, that said plenty about this particular afternoon.

Still, I was pleased with what we'd managed. We'd made fabric with a texture we liked, completed some knitting, and had at least a little success with purling.

We also agreed we'd try again. I enjoyed spending the time with Rachel, even when our fiddly little stitches were getting the better of us, and asked whether viewers would like us to film another attempt.

FAQs

Did you use a turning chain?

We didn't add one during this attempt, and I commented that I liked that part. The directions we were following hadn't told us to make a turning chain.

Could you use yarn instead of the plastic cord?

We discussed that possibility, but we didn't test it. We thought yarn might create more friction, while the smooth cord gave the loops some structure that helped us find them.

Did you try a metal knooking hook?

We talked about trying the metal ones to see whether they felt nicer. We didn't make that comparison during the session, so we couldn't say how much difference it would make.

Could you knook without looking at the stitches?

I couldn't do that during our first attempt. I can crochet without looking as much, but here I needed to watch closely to find the loops and guide the hook through them. Choose a demonstration that matches your dominant hand, whether you need left-handed knooking or right-handed knooking.

How long had you and Rachel been crocheting together?

We worked out that we'd been crocheting together for about a decade. Rachel credited me with convincing her to use a better hook, while I remembered her returning with 126 granny squares and looking like a professional already. We didn't reach the finishing step, when instructions may call securing the final loops "cast off" or "bind off."

Our First Try Was Worth Another Afternoon

Our ten-minute plan produced a 50-minute first try, a few inches of fabric, and one purl row I was particularly pleased to see. The knit stitch had started to make sense, while purling and recovering mistakes still needed work.

I liked the knitted texture enough to keep practicing knooking. Once the stitches feel steadier, I'd like to try a few knooking patterns. More than anything, Rachel and I had a good laugh together, even when those tiny loops refused to cooperate.

Join the yarn party list

Grab my free crochet cheat sheet!

Be the first to hear about new patterns, CALs and sales. Sign up and I'll send you my free crochet cheat sheet as a thank-you!

No spam, just yarny goodness. Unsubscribe anytime.

From Christa's crochet blog

Read it, then hook it!

The Secret Yarnery blog is packed with free crochet tips, stitch tutorials and project ideas, written in plain English for beginners and seasoned hookers alike.

Found a project you love? Grab the easy PDF pattern and follow along with step-by-step video tutorials for both left-handed and right-handed crocheters.